I know it would hurt some feelings and cause some serious ill will, but I wish some politicians were more intent on job destruction. Instead of focusing on creating unnecessary jobs, they should tack and focus on destroying them, at least some of them anyway. I’m not opposed to the people, or even necessarily their performance. But let’s face it, if we’re paying otherwise productive people to be unproductive, then we all lose out. Here are a few professions where employment numbers should be declining:
First, an easy one: Gas pumpers. In New Jersey and Oregon it is still illegal to pump your own gas. I fail to see how these jobs are anything but wasteful.
Second, also obvious: Tax preparers. The tax code is thoroughly convoluted. To say it should be simplified is an understatement. The only argument to the contrary is that we’re used to it, we’ve already planned around it, and change is worse than a bad status quo.
Third, and finally: Teachers. Generally, in any process, we expect efficiency to improve over time. Education bucks this trend. The ongoing fad (can fads really be ongoing?) is to reduce the student:teacher ratio. The fad is based on conventional wisdom, a few studies that support the conventional wisdom, and a both huge and wrong ceteris paribus assumption. The idea to have smaller classrooms is good in theory. But the reality is that additional, affordable teachers are going to be of lower quality; so a lot of kids end up in a smaller group but with a worse teacher. So instead of focusing so much on the number of teachers we have, we should be focusing on how to actually take the best methods and actually apply them equally throughout all classrooms.