During my recent trip, I read a copy of the first Harry Potter book that I recently purchased. And by “read” I mean listened to the audiobook, and by “recently” I mean it’s been in my possession for months, and by “purchased” I mean it was given to me.
I’m not so much saying that the book was bad. In fact, I rather enjoyed listening to it. Having long ago seen the movie (I always like to see the movie first because the books are always better), I pretty much knew what happened. At times while listening, I searched for small lessons or evidence of racism and intolerance upon which I could pontificate. I didn’t notice too much but there was enough that it should enrage uber-liberals, and the whole magic thing should probably upset the uber-conservatives.
The first problem is the same one I have with most books that are fantasy or science fiction. The magic/technology is arbitrarily and absurdly limited to make the story. The fantasy worlds are really always just minor deviations from what we know. Most of the time, there shouldn’t even be a story because the magic/technology would cancel itself out.
The whole house VS house competition is stupid. Points are given and taken almost arbitrarily. Remember when your big brother would suddenly make up a rule, and assign points, and delcare himself the winner? Yeah, it was ridiculous then. It’s ridiculous now. Why should the houses make an effort to compete when the people assigning points can operate almost purely on favoritism?
Also, think about the tasks to get to the stone. Put the dog to sleep with music. Defeat the plant with a little fire. Get past the goblin (someone else did that, thank you very much), catch a key, play some chess, drink some potion, then figure out the mirror. That sure sounds like a lot, but broken up most of these tasks are very much non-challenging and not worthy of being a difficult to breach security system. The mirror is the notable exception — and if you get past it, you’re not stealing the stone for bad reasons anyway.
The other problem is the story of the book itself. At the point when the stone was destroyed I decided I wanted my money back. I had just listened to a training exercise. The not-so-booksmart-but-bound-to-be-great-via-family-bloodline and wonderfully admirable George W. Bush, er, Harry Potter was practically lead by the hand through a meaningless exercise. Yippee.