I’ve been looking for a good wing sauce for quite some time. Back before the Super Bowl, Will at Vodkapundit put forth his recipe. It was really not much different from other variations I’ve tried, but this one worked out pretty well. In the past, sauces were always too thin, and basically ran right off the wings. The main difference with this recipe is the sugar.
As derived from the link above and for the record:
2 cups Frank’s Red Hot sauce
2 tablespoons sugar
2 tablespoons margarine
a few twists of fresh ground black pepper
some kosher salt straight from the box
Everything was combined in a saucepan and whisked together. The directions said to “simmer” the sauce. My oven goes from “lo” to “hi” with 1 thru 9 in the middle. I kept the temperature on 1. I kept the pan covered for the first 90 minutes, then left it uncovered for the remaining hour, stirring every 20 or 30 minutes. The final sauce temperature was around 175ºF.
When the wings finished baking, I poured the sauce in a bowl and dipped the wings in to coat. The sauce coated better and was thicker than most I have tried in the past.
The wings were pretty spicy but not overwhelming, just about the way I like them.
Next time it may be worthwhile to put all the coated wings back in the oven for a couple minutes, and/or to simmer the sauce down a bit more. Overall this is a pretty good working base.